TVD's Paul Wesley with his girlfriend Phoebe Tonkin & Daniel Gillies . Cast of The Originals - Joseph Morgan, Phoebe Tonkin, Claire Holt, Daniel Gillies, and. Tonkin, 24, who was a recurring guest star on “The Vampire Diaries” last “The Originals,” alongside Joseph Morgan and Daniel Gillies. And one of the most vocal and loyal ship fanbases is “Klayley,” aka Klaus ( Joseph Morgan) and Hayley (Phoebe Tonkin). The two hybrids.